SIF vs MF · PMS · AIF
Investment Options Comparison
Compare SIF, MF, PMS, and AIF across key features to find the right strategy for your portfolio.
| Feature | SIFSpecialized Inv. Funds | MFMutual Funds | PMSPortfolio Mgmt | AIFAlt. Inv. Funds |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Minimum Investment | ₹10 Lakh | ₹100 | ₹50 Lakh | ₹1 Crore |
Investor Type | HNI | Retail / HNI | HNI | HNI / Ultra HNI |
STCG (< 12m) | Equity: 20% · Debt: Slab rate | Equity: 20% · Debt: Slab rate | Taxed at each transaction | Category dependent |
LTCG (> 12m) | Equity: 12.5% · Debt: Slab rate | Equity: 12.5% · Debt: Slab rate | Taxed at each transaction | Category dependent |
Derivatives | Up to 25% naked shorts + hedging | Only hedging | Only hedging | Allowed |
Strategy Flexibility | High (long-short, sector rotation) | Limited (mostly long-only diversified) | Customised portfolio | Wide range (PE, credit, hedge, etc.) |
Liquidity | Moderate (close-ended features) | High (daily redemption) | Low (lock-in, redemption restrictions) | Low (close-ended, 5–10 years) |
Why SIF?
The only vehicle combining long-short flexibility with MF-like transparency and a ₹10L entry — purpose-built for HNIs who want hedge-fund-style strategies without the AIF ticket.
Where MF wins
Daily liquidity, ₹100 entry and pure long-only simplicity still make mutual funds the default for retail SIPs and core allocation.
Where AIF/PMS win
For ₹1Cr+ tickets needing private equity, credit or fully bespoke portfolios, AIF and PMS remain the only real options — SIFs don't replace them.
Taxation figures reflect Budget 2024 changes. Dummy data for illustration — consult a tax advisor.
