K
KiAlt Advisor
RS
SIF vs MF · PMS · AIF

Investment Options Comparison

Compare SIF, MF, PMS, and AIF across key features to find the right strategy for your portfolio.

Feature
SIFSpecialized Inv. Funds
MFMutual Funds
PMSPortfolio Mgmt
AIFAlt. Inv. Funds
Minimum Investment
₹10 Lakh₹100₹50 Lakh₹1 Crore
Investor Type
HNIRetail / HNIHNIHNI / Ultra HNI
STCG (< 12m)
Equity: 20% · Debt: Slab rateEquity: 20% · Debt: Slab rateTaxed at each transactionCategory dependent
LTCG (> 12m)
Equity: 12.5% · Debt: Slab rateEquity: 12.5% · Debt: Slab rateTaxed at each transactionCategory dependent
Derivatives
Up to 25% naked shorts + hedgingOnly hedgingOnly hedgingAllowed
Strategy Flexibility
High (long-short, sector rotation)Limited (mostly long-only diversified)Customised portfolioWide range (PE, credit, hedge, etc.)
Liquidity
Moderate (close-ended features)High (daily redemption)Low (lock-in, redemption restrictions)Low (close-ended, 5–10 years)

Why SIF?

The only vehicle combining long-short flexibility with MF-like transparency and a ₹10L entry — purpose-built for HNIs who want hedge-fund-style strategies without the AIF ticket.

Where MF wins

Daily liquidity, ₹100 entry and pure long-only simplicity still make mutual funds the default for retail SIPs and core allocation.

Where AIF/PMS win

For ₹1Cr+ tickets needing private equity, credit or fully bespoke portfolios, AIF and PMS remain the only real options — SIFs don't replace them.

Taxation figures reflect Budget 2024 changes. Dummy data for illustration — consult a tax advisor.